Tuesday, November 27, 2007

PS - fish tank

A fish tank is half full of water. If 10 gallons were added, the tank would be 7/8 full. What is the capacity of the tank (in gallons)?

A. 11 3/7
B. 22 3/7
C. 26 2/3
D. 30 3/8
E. 32 1/8


source: http://www.800score.com/gmat/

7 comments:

Luís Botelho Ribeiro said...

If the adition of 10 gallons yields the transition from half tank (4/8) to 7/8 of the tank filled (a step of 3/8), then the total capacity is easily obtained as 10/(3/8) or 80/3. This number can be expressed in the form n m/3, and none of the other options with 7 or 8 in the denominator. In fact, (3, 7) and (3, 8) form twin prime pairs. Thus, the 80/3 results would never be expresseable in a form n m/7 or n m/8. The correct option can only be option C.

jfd said...

Can you try and explain that again in portuguese?
thank you!

Francisco Saraiva said...

If you try to add water to a full tank it will spill!!! :)

The correct question is:

A fish tank is half full of water. If 10 gallons were added, the tank would be 7/8 full. What is the capacity of the tank (in gallons)?

Luís Botelho Ribeiro said...

Francisco Saraiva, thanks. The word "half" was missing. I agree the "solution" is not as clear as required. Let me put it another way - but still in english, for the "world" to be able to follow our discussion:

10 gallons correspond to 3/8 of the tank, This results clearly from the enunciate. So the tank capacity is 10 gallons divided by 3/8 - which is 80/3. Such a rational number could never be expressed as a mixed number of type * */7 for the simple reason that 3 and 7 form a twin prime pair. The same reason holds for the form * */8. So, our only remaining option is answer C.

Drèzith said...

If X="Water Capacity", then:

X/2+10=(7/8)X <=> X=26.66(7)

Answer C.

Nuno said...

JFD em PT:

o tanque inicialmente está a metade da sua capacidade máxima (1/2 ou 4/8). Ao adicionar 10gls passa a 7/8 logo os 10gls representam um aumento de 3/8.

Considerando x a capacidade do tanque:
10gallons = 3/8x, então x = 80/3

Para encontrar a opção correcta bastaria encontrar a opção expressa em n*m/3, e seria a opção C. No entanto surge nova questão:

80/3 = 26,7
26 2/3 = 17,3 os resultados n coincidem!!!!

Can someone please explain the inconsistency?? tnks

João Pedro Neto said...

Nuno:

26 2/3 não é 26 vezes 2/3, mas sim 26 + 2/3 =26,(6)

Não existe sinal de multiplicar entre eles (nem sequer se está simplesmente a omitir).